Journalist reflects on Israel's deep divisions

Lucas Menget, a journalist who has covered Israel for over 25 years, expressed surprise at how deeply divided Israeli society has become as the country approaches legislative elections on October 27, 2026. He described an "existential crisis" in Israel, with many people considering leaving if the current government remains in power.

Societal fractures explored in documentary

The documentary Israel, a Democracy in Peril examines the deep fractures in Israeli society, shaped by the trauma of October 7, 2023, the war in Gaza, and ongoing regional conflicts. It focuses on the growing tension between the government and the judiciary, which many view as a key pillar of Israel's democracy.

Challenges in assembling diverse perspectives

Menget aimed to go beyond the protest movement against judicial reform by speaking with a wide range of individuals, including former intelligence officials, lawyers, and religious leaders. However, convincing people with opposing views to participate was difficult, with some, like former Supreme Court President Dorit Beinisch, hesitant to appear in the film.

Questioning the foundation of Israeli identity

The documentary raises questions about what binds Israelis to their state, a relationship often defined by a promise of protection in exchange for collective sacrifice. Menget suggests that this foundation has been shaken, especially after the events of October 7, which left many questioning the values that still underpin this relationship.

Religious influence and identity concerns

The film highlights how the religious right has gained increasing political influence, particularly through the coalition led by Prime Minister Netanyahu. This has raised concerns that Jewish identity in Israel may be increasingly defined by religious rather than cultural or historical factors, a shift that does not resonate with all Israelis.

Gaza's role in Israeli public discourse

While the conflict in Gaza and accusations of genocide dominate international attention on Israel, these issues are often absent from the immediate concerns of many Israelis. Menget describes this as a paradox, comparing it to a "monster in the next room" that Israelis are reluctant to confront, even as they are aware of the suffering in Gaza.

Return of the West Bank to public consciousness

Recent events have brought the West Bank back into focus for some Israelis, as they reconsider the consequences of settlement expansion and associated violence. The documentary captures the internal contradictions of a society grappling with the tension between its founding ideals and the choices that challenge them.

Documentary broadcast on France 5

Israel, a Democracy in Peril was broadcast on Sunday, October 25 at 21:00 on France 5, offering a rare glimpse into the internal struggles of a nation at a critical crossroads.