A tidal power plant built in 1966 has transformed the Rance estuary into a mudflat, revealing the hidden environmental costs of renewable energy.
A greyish mudflat at low tide
A greyish mudflat stretching as far as the eye can see, where generations of Bretons have seen sailboats and cormorants dive between two clear waters: this is the face that part of the Rance estuary presents at low tide today. This almost mineral landscape is not natural. It is the direct consequence of an industrial choice dating back several decades, that of wanting to harness the power of tides to produce electricity.The Rance tidal power plant
A concrete wall that has tamed the tide. It all starts with an engineering feat celebrated at the time as a worldwide first. By blocking the estuary with a 750-meter embankment, EDF built a structure capable of transforming the simple back-and-forth of tides into electricity. The principle is as elegant as it is radical: water flows into tidal turbines during the rising tide, then exits during the falling tide, generating an electric current with each movement.The tidal prism and its decline
When water no longer flows, mud takes over. To understand the problem, one must look at a key concept in coastal hydrology: the tidal prism, that is, the volume of water entering and exiting the estuary with each cycle. Before the construction of the dam, this prism allowed for a genuine natural cleaning: the ebb current, that of the falling tide, was powerful enough to carry sediments out to sea.Sediment accumulation and dredging
Thousands of tons of sediments to be extracted each year. Facing this continuous accumulation, it has been necessary to organize a real cleaning logistics. A sustainable management plan for the Rance has been put in place to regulate regular dredging operations aimed at extracting the sediments that accumulate seasonally. These projects, carried out by barges and specialized equipment, mobilize considerable resources to remove impressive volumes of mud year after year, without ever being able to put an end to the phenomenon.The long-term consequences
Fifty years later, an estuary still under perfusion. For several decades, residents, boaters, and local officials have observed, sometimes with a certain weariness, this phenomenon that seems to have no programmed end. Associations such as Rance Environnement have been formed to voice the concerns of those who live daily with the consequences of this siltation: loss of depth for boats, retreat of swimming areas, gradual alteration of landscapes that have made the reputation of this part of Brittany.