New French Phantom of the Opera film premieres

A new French adaptation of The Phantom of the Opera, based on the 1911 novel by Gaston Leroux, has opened in theaters. The film, directed by Julien De Saint Jean and starring Deva Cassel, was produced with a budget of 20 million euros and includes dancers from the company of Dorothée Gilbert. It follows Anastasia, a young dancer who joins the Paris Opera and becomes involved in a mysterious love story with a pianist while rehearsing a cursed opera composed by the Phantom.

Setting at the Garnier Opera House

The film was shown at the Garnier Opera House in Paris, which plays a central role in the story. The real-life opera house, known for its grand architecture and historical significance, adds authenticity to the film's setting and visual appeal.

Mixed audience reviews on AlloCiné

Audience reactions on AlloCiné, a French film review platform, are mixed. The film currently has an average rating of 3 out of 5, based on 196 reviews and 99 critiques. Positive feedback focuses on the film's costumes, choreography, and music, with several viewers praising its romantic elements and visual splendor.

Praise for costumes and performances

Several critics and viewers highlighted the film's sumptuous costumes and choreography. Anais R. (5/5) called it "a singular film" with "sublime staging" and "a love story with fully assumed romanticism." Candela (5/5) described it as a "cinematic masterpiece" with "stunning performances," while Laeti_b45 (5/5) admired the "crazy" choreography and "sumptuous costumes."

Criticism of plot and character development

However, some viewers found the story predictable and the characters unconvincing. Chiara Garcia (3.5/5) noted that while the film had "exceptional shots," the plot was "predictable" and "a bit pulled by the hair." Clembtps (3/5) called it a "disappointing" adaptation that failed to capture the full potential of the original myth.

Divided opinions on narrative and setting

While the film's visual elements and the use of the Garnier Opera House are widely praised, opinions on the narrative and character development remain divided. Some viewers found the story lacking depth, while others appreciated the film's romantic and visual aspects.