Manchester United have shown a noticeable shift in performance depending on how much of the ball they control during matches. When they have less than 50% of the ball, they average 2.6 points per game, compared to just 1.5 points when they dominate possession. This trend has been particularly evident since the start of last season, where United won all 10 games when their ball possession dropped to 45% or below. This has sparked discussions about how the team can effectively transition from a counter-attacking style to one that can consistently beat teams that control the game. In a recent derby match, Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca highlighted how a red card significantly altered the dynamics of the game. He noted that United's usual strategy of relying on quick transitions and exploiting space behind defenses became more difficult once the team was forced to play with a numerical disadvantage. In response, Maresca’s team adapted by reducing the space available behind their defense and limiting the opportunities for United to launch quick counterattacks. The debate over United's playing style has brought the concept of "United DNA" back into focus, a term that has long been associated with the club's identity. Current manager Michael Carrick has emphasized the importance of playing in a way that excites fans, a philosophy that echoes the legacy of former manager Sir Alex Ferguson, who also valued entertaining football. Carrick's approach has focused on proactivity, direct play, and creating excitement, which aligns with the strengths of the current squad, including goalkeeper Senne Lammens, defenders Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez, and attackers like Marcus Rashford and Bruno Fernandes. However, Carrick’s style has also exposed some tactical weaknesses. When United are in possession, breaking down strong defenses requires effective one-on-one wingers, but the team lacks players who are strong dribblers. Players like Luke Shaw, Patrick Dorgu, Diogo Dalot, and Bryan Mbeumo are not the most adept at taking on defenders in tight spaces. Carrick has often used a 4-2-4 formation in possession, which has left the wide players isolated. Additionally, the use of a floating front two with Bruno Fernandes and Matheus Cunha has led to a lack of players in the box when crosses are played, as both are more comfortable facing the opposition’s goal rather than working in tight areas. Set-pieces have historically been a key component of United's success, with 56% of their opening goals last season coming from corners, free-kicks, or penalties. However, this season, the team has not shown the same effectiveness in these situations. The absence of Casemiro, who was particularly strong in scoring from headers, has made it more difficult for United to break down deep-lying defenses. This has highlighted the need for the team to develop alternative methods of scoring when they are not in possession.