Teatro Real opens with Manon Lescaut

The Teatro Real in Madrid began its lyrical season with a new production of Manon Lescaut by Giacomo Puccini, directed by Carlos Wagner. This marked the first time the opera had been performed at the theater in 102 years, and the production was set in the 1960s, which led to some anachronisms, including references to Louisiana's deportation, a policy that no longer exists today.

Set design features distinct scenes

The set design, created by Frank Philipp Schlössmann, included four distinct settings. Act I took place in a fairground with a carousel of wooden horses, Act II in a luxurious apartment, Act III in a metal cage that served as a prison, and Act IV in a desert space with a gigantic black hole, creating a visually striking but sometimes confusing backdrop.

Cast highlights and challenges

Soprano Sondra Radvanovsky, who played the title role, was the main attraction, praised for her powerful voice and emotional intensity. However, she struggled to convey the innocence and youth of Manon in the early acts. Conductor Nicola Luisotti led the orchestra from the pit, and the vocal cast was described as varied, with some performances noted for their strengths and others for their shortcomings.

Criticisms and standout performances

Tenor Michael Fabiano faced criticism for his performance as Des Grieux, particularly in his first aria, "Donna non vidi mai," which was seen as lacking elegance. Lucas Meachem portrayed Lescaut as rough and manipulative, with a strong voice but inconsistent phrasing. Mercedes Gancedo stood out as a promising new talent, singing with fresh and delicate tones as the young madrigal singer.

Chorus and musical direction praised

The Choir of the Teatro Real, led by José Luis Basso, was praised for its flawless performance throughout the opera. Nicola Luisotti's conducting was highlighted as strong and effective, and the production was noted for its balance between stage and music. The Intermezzo, initiated by the cello of Simon Veis, was described as superb and emotionally moving.