New research suggests that praising young children for being smart might have unexpected effects, potentially increasing the chances that they will cheat in future situations. The study, conducted in China and published in the Journal of Educational Psychology, involved 210 children between the ages of 5 and 6. These children were given a test that was designed to ensure they would all succeed. After completing the test, each child received a different explanation for their performance. Some were told they were smart, while others were told they had worked hard, were lucky, or had faced an easy task. Some children received no explanation at all.
Children who were praised for being smart were nearly twice as likely to cheat on a later task compared to those who received other explanations or no explanation. In this "temptation task," the children had an opportunity to cheat when an adult left the room. The results suggest that being told they were smart made these children feel greater pressure to maintain their image of being intelligent. This pressure might have led them to consider cheating as a way to preserve that image when faced with a difficult task.
Cheating in young children is often thought to be linked to poor impulse control or an inability to regulate their behavior. However, this study and other research suggest that even young children can make thoughtful decisions about whether to cheat, considering the possible rewards and risks, and even making moral judgments about whether cheating is acceptable.
Praising a child for being smart can immediately increase their confidence, but it may also create a pressure to keep up that image. If a task feels too challenging, children might avoid it altogether, leading to quitting or putting in less effort. In contrast, focusing on effort rather than innate ability might be a more effective way to build confidence and reduce the urge to cheat. For example, praising a child for working hard rather than for being naturally talented can encourage persistence and resilience.
The study highlights the importance of how feedback is given to children. Parents and teachers might consider praising effort with statements like, "You worked really hard on that—great job!" This approach can be more beneficial in the long run. Additionally, directly encouraging honesty and praising children for being good have been shown to reduce cheating behavior. These findings suggest that the way we communicate with children can shape not only their self-perception but also their ethical choices.
Praise for Intelligence May Influence Cheating Behavior in Young Children
AI-rewritten from original reportingHow it works
child-developmenteducationcheatingpraisebehavior
Original sources:
- 🇺🇸Phys.org



