As a new "All Stars" season of the reality TV show Koh-Lanta airs, the show's signature "island of the exiled" format has sparked mixed reactions among viewers. This format involves contestants being sent to a separate island after being voted out, where they face challenges and may have opportunities to return to the main game. While it has become a hallmark of the series, some fans are growing critical of the strategy and fairness of the mechanic. Claude Dartois, a former contestant who gained significant attention during his time on the show, recently expressed his disappointment with the current season. On Tuesday, September 8, 2026, Dartois took to Instagram to voice his concerns about how the game has evolved. He highlighted what he sees as a shift in the show's original spirit, suggesting that the new format may be undermining the strategic and psychological elements that made Koh-Lanta unique. Dartois, who became a fan favorite during his participation in an earlier season, emphasized that the "island of the exiled" concept was once a clever way to add depth and tension to the competition. However, he feels that the current implementation lacks the same level of strategy and fairness. His comments have sparked a broader conversation among fans about whether the show is losing its original appeal. The Koh-Lanta franchise has always been known for its intense gameplay and unpredictable twists, but changes to its core mechanics can affect how audiences engage with the show. As the new "All Stars" season continues, it remains to be seen whether the format will be adjusted or if the criticism will lead to a reevaluation of how the game is structured for future seasons.