Philosopher calls for reconnecting with tangible objects

Philosopher Fanny Lederlin argues in her essay Ersatz that society should reconnect with physical objects and manual actions in a world increasingly shaped by digital tools and virtual experiences. She believes that focusing on real, material things can help restore a meaningful relationship with the world.

Digital mediation and loss of meaning

Lederlin points out that modern life is becoming more dematerialized, relying heavily on digital technologies, apps, and AI-driven systems. She warns that this shift risks making objects lose their significance and meaning, as people become less attentive to the physical world around them.

Historical movements and thinkers

Lederlin’s ideas align with a broader intellectual movement that values direct, hands-on experiences. She references thinkers like William Morris, Walter Benjamin, and Matthew B. Crawford, who have long emphasized the importance of tangible engagement with objects and the dangers of over-reliance on technology.

Paradox of a saturated world

She describes a paradox in which the world is filled with objects, ideas, and images, yet people are unable to connect with them meaningfully. This, she argues, stems from a lack of attention and engagement with the material world, which has become overwhelming and unresponsive.

Rediscovering manual work and care

Lederlin suggests that a return to manual labor and craftsmanship could help societies reconnect with tangible objects. She highlights the value of work that involves direct interaction with things, as seen in Matthew B. Crawford’s book In Praise of the Carburetor, which celebrates the importance of hands-on skills.

A call for ecological and social change

Lederlin believes that restoring a relationship with physical objects can have both ecological and existential benefits. She urges a reevaluation of economic and political values to recognize and support trades like agriculture, repair, and maintenance, promoting a new "care order" rooted in attention and responsibility.