In the north-west corner of Devon, two men with contrasting visions for the land live as neighbors: Derek Gow, a passionate advocate for rewilding, and Derek Banbury, a traditional intensive farmer. Gow, known for reintroducing beavers to England, is working to restore natural ecosystems on his sheep farm, where he breeds a variety of wildlife, including storks, wildcats, and adders. Across the hedge, Banbury manages a high-yield dairy and beef operation, maintaining tightly clipped hedges and efficient agricultural practices. While Banbury calls Gow’s methods "madness," the two men share a complex relationship shaped by mutual respect and the shared love of animals.
Documentarian James Dawson originally planned to film Gow’s rewilding efforts but found himself capturing the evolving dynamic between the two men. Both have a strong personality, a sharp business sense, and a deep connection to the land. Gow, a fiery Scottish speaker, criticizes both the slow pace of conservation efforts and the way some farmers use public funds for unnecessary expenses. Banbury, on the other hand, defends intensive farming as essential for feeding a growing global population. Despite his unapologetic stance, he has begun to reflect on the environmental costs of his practices.
Linda Banbury, Derek’s wife, plays a pivotal role in the documentary, advocating for a balanced approach that includes tolerance for wildlife like beavers. The film, which has been well-received at festivals in Greece and Sheffield, has even prompted Banbury to consider a new suit for its London premiere. The documentary highlights the tensions between rewilding and intensive farming, such as when Gow’s wild boar intrude on Banbury’s pasture, leading to a conflict that culminates in the boar’s removal. Banbury remains skeptical of the ecological benefits of beavers, while Gow argues that farmers could help reverse the extinction crisis by setting aside land for wildlife.
As the film progresses, both men begin to recognize the value of each other’s perspectives. Banbury admits that areas like Gow’s farm are necessary for wildlife, and he even considers allowing some hedges to grow wild if compensated. Gow, in turn, suggests that farmers could be paid to breed and release rare animals, fostering a collaborative approach. The documentary ends on a hopeful note, with neighbors and farmers attending a special screening where the two men, despite their differences, find common ground. As Gow says, “when the film finished, no one was arguing” against the reality of nature loss.
The film aims to spark new conversations and relationships between farmers, conservationists, and rewilders across the country. In a touching final scene, the two Deryks are seen as unlikely friends, with Banbury acknowledging that their neighborly bond means they would support each other in any situation. Their story, filled with conflict and mutual respect, offers a glimpse into the potential for coexistence between agriculture and nature.
Neighbors at Odds Over Farming and Rewilding Find Common Ground
AI-rewritten from original reportingHow it works
rewildingfarmingconservationneighborsdocumentaryland-management



